Reality check for eurozone growth expectations
- Our eurozone growth forecast for 2021 has remained relatively steady and consistently below market consensus and official institutions' forecasts.
- The latter are shifting downwards, however, as the harsh reality of widespread COVID-19-driven containment measures dawns.
- National and sectoral variations in those restrictions, and their subsequent easing, means the recent "noise" in economic data will persist.
- We continue to expect a consumer-led growth spurt from Q2 onwards.
IHS Markit recently updated its growth forecasts. Our forecast for 2021 annual growth in the eurozone was edged up, to 3.8%, reflecting the smaller than initially expected q/q decline in GDP in Q4 2020 (revised to -0.6%) but also a slight offset from the minor downward adjustment to our q/q estimate for Q1 2021 (to -1.0%).
Downward adjustment to external forecasts
Chart 1 highlights a striking divergence of forecasters' eurozone growth expectations for 2021. While IHS Markit's forecast has remained relatively steady, and sub-4%, market consensus expectations and those of official institutions (in this case the European Commission) were way too optimistic initially but have fallen back markedly since. Back in mid-2020, the consensus and the Commission's 2021 forecasts were both in excess of 6%.
IHS Markit's current forecast of 3.8% remains below the current market consensus expectation (of 4.4%, based on February's Consensus Economics). Following the European Commission's latest downgrade in February's "winter" update, its forecast now matches IHS Markit's estimate.
Beware of annual growth rates
In such volatile times, annual estimates are a sub-optimal guide to growth trajectories. As in 2020, the quarterly path of GDP changes this year will be exceptionally bumpy due primarily to the effects of COVID-19 containment measures and their subsequent reversal.
Q1's GDP figures, which will be available from late April, will confirm a second post-COVID-19 recession in the eurozone, albeit much less severe than the first. But from Q2 onwards, we continue to expect a compensating growth spurt, as COVID-19 restrictions ease due to vaccination roll-outs and seasonal influences.
As in Q3 2020, we expect private consumption to lead the pick-up, rebounding strongly following significant COVID-19 disruption in the prior two quarters, with household savings rates declining following unprecedented increases in the first half of 2020.
How soon for the rebound?
While annual growth estimates for 2021 are now the same, IHS Markit's quarterly path for eurozone GDP growth is different in one notable respect from the European Commission's latest estimates. We expect the rebound to begin in Q2 and to continue during Q3, whereas the Commission expects the rebound to be concentrated in the latter quarter only, reflecting different assumptions about the speed of the unwind of COVID-19 restrictions.
Thereafter, eurozone q/q growth rates in both forecasts are expected to moderate to a much more gradual pace of around 0.5% q/q, through into 2022. As base effects will be very favourable for y/y rates of change in eurozone GDP from Q2 this year onwards, we think it more likely than not that the annual growth rate in 2022 will actually exceed that in 2021 despite the much lower trajectory of growth rates. This is another example of why annual rates of change should be treated with caution.
Divergence of GDP "crossovers"
We expect the "crossover" in eurozone GDP (that is, the quarter in which it will surpass its pre-COVID-19 level) in Q3 2022, much later than 2021's forecast "crossovers" in the US and Canada, in part due to the next slug of large-scale US fiscal stimulus.
GDP "crossovers" will also vary considerably across the eurozone's member states, in line with divergent growth forecasts, including for 2021. These variations in performance reflecting a range of factors, including the relative magnitude of 2020's GDP declines, recent divergence of COVID-19 trends, related restrictions and approaches to containment, differences in exposure to the most and least affected sectors of activity, plus variations in vaccination roll-outs and policy support.
Long story short, the more manufacturing-driven, less indebted "northern" economies will experience their GDP "crossovers" much earlier (think Germany) than the consumer services-sensitive, more indebted "southern" economies (think Greece).
But again, this may not necessarily be reflected in annual growth forecasts for 2021, as Chart 3 illustrates. Those that suffered comparatively smaller declines in 2020, like Germany, will have less scope to rebound this year.
Look through data volatility
"Noise" in economic indicators across member states and sectors will continue to make interpretation of data challenging going forward. The initial estimates of GDP in Q4 2020 are a case in point.
Of the eleven largest economies of the eurozone, Austria fared worst (-4.3% q/q) and Spain and Portugal outperformed (both +0.4% q/q). But these data points are in no way indicative of their relative performances during the COVID-19 shock.
The latest retail sales data, for December last year, offer another example of exceptionally "noisy" data. While Germany saw a near-10% m/m collapse in sales volumes, France experienced a 20%-plus m/m rebound. Differences in the timing of COVID-19 restrictions in the eurozone's two largest member states contributed to this unprecedented divergence. More than ever before, individual data points need to be set in the wider economic context.
- The ascent of APAC in the global economy
- Weekly Pricing Pulse: Commodity prices slide on renewed demand fears
- Global recession watch: Inflation at a fever pitch
- Banking risk monthly outlook: August 2022
- Weekly Pricing Pulse: Commodity prices rise on renewed energy supply fears
- US Monthly GDP Index for June 2022
- What Europe’s gas curtailment plan will do to industries and regions
- Did the US economy contract over the first half of 2022? It’s a tale of two measures
RT @ChrisVarvares: With employment and IP up strongly, it is safe to say recession did not arrive in July.
Worsening asset quality in Bangladesh and Pakistan, foreign exchange risks in Argentina, Chile and Costa Rica, fint… https://t.co/nOLO1i7hga