Bone Spring: A sleeping giant
The Bone Spring play continues to compete with other headline unconventional plays across the Lower 48 in daily output, producing about 460,000 boe/d (6:1) for much of 2017. Compared with other major oil plays, such as the Eagle Ford and Wolfcamp Delaware, the Bone Spring ranked first in productivity from January 2016 to July 2017, averaging around 170 boe/d per 1,000 lateral ft (20:1).
Although most Bone Spring operators have settled on relatively short laterals of around 4,000-5,000 ft play, some operators have found success in longer laterals—notably, Concho and EOG. A significant step change in completion size took place around mid-2016, when operators began ramping up proppant loads from 1,500 lb/ft to around 2,000 lb/ft; EOG has been the most aggressive, achieving strong results. Other operators do continue to find success using around 1,500-2,000 lb/ft of proppant in recent wells—most notably, Occidental and Mewbourne. Activity in the Bone Spring has waned since its peak in 2014; however, encouraging economics hint that a rebound in activity across the play is near, as operators continue to delineate the play while they focus on developing the deeper Wolfcamp Formation.
Bone Spring: Location and overview
The Permian Basin formed as a foreland basin during the Oachita-Marathon Orogeny, which was later divided into two main subbasins: the steeply dipping Delaware Basin to the west and the shallow-dipping Midland Basin to the east.
The Delaware Basin has several stacked plays, particularly within the Permian-age part of the stratigraphic section, where the Bone Spring Sands are situated. The sandy formations of the Delaware Mountain Group above the Bone Spring contain hydrocarbon reservoirs, as well as the underlying Wolfcamp Formation, a prolific horizontal play.
The Bone Spring play has historically been subdivided into three informal sand units: the First, Second, and Third Bone Spring Sands. Each sand is overlaid by a carbonate-rich interval. The Avalon Shale play has been an emerging target in recent years, and is situated above the First Bone Spring Sand and underneath the Bone Spring Lime. The Avalon Shale is subdivided into the Upper Avalon Shale and Lower Avalon Shale.
Figure 1: Stratigraphic column of Pennsylvanian through Permian-age strata in the Delaware Basin
The Bone Spring Formation reaches a maximum gross thickness of 3,400 ft. in Loving County, and is found at depths of 8,000–11,000 ft. Thickness of the individual sands varies from 180–500 ft. Both the Upper and Lower Avalon Shale members are generally 100-200 ft in thickness, reaching a maximum thickness of approximately 250-280 ft in eastern Eddy and Loving counties.
What to watch: Recent activity focused in New Mexico Bone Spring
Occidental, EOG, and Devon have been the most active operators in the Bone Spring in 2017, spudding nearly 70 new wells combined between May and November 2017. Despite having spud 10 new wells, Concho has only 8 permits filed in the same timeframe, indicating that it is focused more on its Wolfcamp operations in both the Delaware and Midland basins.
Figure 2: Bone Spring spud and permit activity by operator: May – November 2017
Following ExxonMobil’s sizable acquisition of BOPCO earlier this year, it has demonstrated its determination to start developing the Bone Spring, filing permits for nearly 40 new well locations between May and November 2017.
What to watch: Bone Spring oil and gas production outlook
Activity in the Bone Spring waned considerably from 2015 through year-end 2016, with production hovering around 430,000 boe/d (6:1) through early 2017 (see figure 3). Despite reaching a production plateau in recent years, the play is poised for growth in early 2018.
Figure 3: Bone Spring production forecast
IHS Markit predicts production will continue to climb, reaching up to 1.25 MMboe (6:1) by 2021, as operators begin to ramp up activity in the play and optimize development of its prolific stacked pay zones.
Lauren Droege is a Senior Analyst and Geologist supporting the North America Onshore team in the greater Commercial Plays and Basins group.
Posted 12 February 2018
- North American E&P hedging strategies for 2018
- Latin American NOCs set to increase capital spending in 2018
- Taiwan seeks to scale up offshore renewables while phasing out nuclear
- Mapping out Mexico’s conventional gas potential
- CNPC and ONGC acquire strategic resources and can expect near-term payout from Abu Dhabi concessions
- High-voltage power transmission in China: A long-distance relationship cooling off
- What’s trending in the global upstream mergers and acquisitions market?
- What you need to know: Second quarter 2018 production forecast